Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

Salt Island: The Forgotten & Neglected Island- Part 2 of 3

Salt Island is one of the islands of the archipelago of the British Virgin Islands located about 4.7 miles south east of Road Town, the main town on Tortola. Photo: Google Earth
Edgar Leonard. Photo: Provided
Edgar Leonard. Photo: Provided
Edgar Leonard

Part 1 attempted to provide a cursory peek of the proud, hardy, industrious, resolute people; the place; the process of the simple, basic living and survival; the inadequate public sector/policy support; the iconic and famous salt ponds; and the Wreck of the Rhone. In Part 2, I will attempt to flesh out some of these topics and expand into additional areas.

Early Inhabitants

The early inhabitants of the Virgin Islands (British) seemed to include a) the nomadic Ciboney Indians who supposedly migrated from South America, b) Arawaks, c) cannibalistic Caribs, d) western European explorers/settlers, and e) African slaves. It is likely that some, but it is not clear which inhabitants resided on Salt Island. However, it is clear that slaves and their descendants lived on Salt Island. Nonetheless, it is still not clear why slaves were on Salt Island. Was it for agricultural production, salt ponds, natural beauty, quiet and enjoyment, or slave breeding site? The answer to these questions may or may not be conclusively answered. Nevertheless, it is my/our precious ancestral homeland.

Water and Other Utilities

Water is life, and fresh, clean water is a precious resource. However, Salt Island is a water-challenged island/community. Per cousins and Salt Island residents Daisy Smith Durante, Lilymae Durante, Nora Smith Mann, and Arlene Smith Crabbe, the early water sources were from a well near the small pond heading towards Lee Bay. Residents collected water from the well for domestic potable uses. Additionally, after heavy rain, water collected in rocks in the hills above the small pond. Residents capitalize on this temporary water source and use it to wash clothes. Later the government constructed a public cistern near the Salt House in 1959.

Further, in the transition from grass/thatch houses to wood with galvanized or felt roofs, residents captured runoff from the roofs into 55-gallon oil drums. Residents covered the drums typically with flour bags to keep mosquitoes from reproducing wriggles and poured a few drops of kerosene into drums to prevent mosquito reproduction. Moreover, in the modern era, property owners constructed new homes with cisterns; Uncle Clarence Smith was the first to build a detached cistern at his home on Salt Island in 1948-1949.

Moreover, Salt Island was a utility and infrastructure desert. It had no electricity, central sewer system/indoor plumbing, water plant/running water, telephones, improved roads, motorized vehicles/transportation, etc. These utilities and infrastructure are still lacking on Salt Island, albeit Salt Island is currently uninhabited. Henry Leonard aka 'Chicken', my brother, the last permanent resident, relocated in 2008. Thus, these systems are vital considerations in any development/repopulation planning.

Education and Family Separation

Though Salt Island was a small, vibrant community with a population that peaked at approximately 100 people, it had no formal school(s). The Anglican Church constructed a small school on the island in 1837, but its existence was short-lived. It was destroyed in an 1837 hurricane and never reopened (Dr Charles H. Wheatley; Voices and Visions of Education Heroes, Leaders, and Elders (2019)). Incidentally, Dr Wheatley hails from Salt Island heritage.

Moreover, the small school closed, parents, especially mothers, had to beat the bushes to locate families, friends, and others on the Tortola mainland and Virgin Gorda for their children to live with to attend school. In most situations, children landed in a home, not just a place to stay; others had indentured servitude experiences.

Further, mothers and fathers stood teary-eyed and emotional on Salt Island Bay, watching their 4- or 5-year-old sail off to attend school. Painfully, as it turns out, many parents didn’t know that they would only see and interact with some of their children infrequently after the emotional departures. During school holidays, some children had to share the time off between their families on Salt Island and their off-island custodians; they spent more time off-island than with their parents. Moreover, though government/churches funded the public schools, parents bore the other costs. Sending children off to Tortola and Virgin Gorda was vital, but it had a huge opportunity cost. It separated families; it robbed children of the joy and priceless opportunity of growing up together. Most siblings sent off to school on Tortola, and Virgin Gorda rarely resided together in the same home. The above setting describes the Salt Island experience, but it was a similar experience on Cooper Island, Peter Island, and other Southern Cays (Key). Keeping families together was but one of many factors that influenced the families’ difficult decision to relocate to Tortola, contributing to the population decline on Salt Island.

Jobs/Employment/ Food Security

Earlier, I noted that slaves inhabited Salt Island. Slaves were workhorses who produced value for profit for their owners, i.e., sugar, cotton, indigo, or tobacco. Tobacco was most probably grown for home consumption. It (Salt Island) was too small and hilly for a profitable sugar plantation, and cotton was likely grown for profit. My grandfather William Leonard aka 'Bulla', a storyteller extraordinaire, on the way to the Sound one early morning spotted a cotton plant just merely starting to sprout from the ground. Upon his return, in the afternoon, it had already borne cotton. Lol.

Moreover, post-slavery Salt Island had no forced sunup to sundown jobs on a more serious note. All of the residents were self-employed or operated small cooperatives, i.e., seine fishing, goat herding, etc. The most probable source of employment and income was picking salt. Salt Island has two salt ponds integrally connected through unique geological features, i.e., seawater seeps/infiltrates into one pond (pond near Lee Bay) and flows into the large pond through a canal.

Salt Island had a thriving salt industry. In the days before commercially packaged salt and the widespread use of refrigeration, naval and other vessels would purchase salt for seasonings and preserving meat, pork, fish, etc. Harvesting of salt was a significant event and celebration, starting with the Commissioner/Administrator firing a gun to signal the start of the ‘Salt Breaking’ event. The official salt-breaking event commenced, the festivities began with feasting, dancing, etc.; the bacchanal lasted for approximately a week or more. Non-islanders were permitted to pick salt for two days, and after the two days elapsed, only Salt Islanders could pick salt. Presumably, under the Salt Pond Act, one kerosene pan of salt had to be given to the Crown for every three kerosene pans of salt picked. The salt given to the Crown was stored in the Government Salt House, managed by the local government representative. After the Wreck of the Rhone, Queen Victoria, for care and compassion Salt Islanders showed towards the decease, supposedly stipulated that Salt Islanders and their descendants would own Salt Island for their use and quiet and enjoy in perpetuity.

Additionally, the government reduced the prior requirement of supposedly contributing 33% of salt picked to the Crown and instituted a one (1) ceremonial bag per year. The demand for salt decreased, residents engaged and depended primarily on fishing, small stock raising, farming, remittances from a family(s) off-island, etc., for income. Another factor contributing to the decline in the Salt Island population was the emigration by younger Salt Islanders to Tortola, St Thomas, etc., to pursue employment. Further, Salt Islanders were relatively secure in food production, particularly in meat kind, i.e., fish, pork, goats, whelks, turtle, conchs, birds, etc.

Leisure

Salt Islanders were proud, hardworking, industrious, and resolute people with a rich history, culture, and heritage. However, life on Salt Island was as simple and as basic as it gets; it was idyllic, yet no picnic with little time for leisure or planned time off. Life was hard. They were up from dawn to the late evening. They employed work to dispel some of the, perhaps, boredom, isolation, and loneliness. For leisure, they would watch man-o-wars, schooners, and other boats sailing by, engage in debate about local, regional, and international events, read whatever information was available, throw back a few adult beverages, tell stories, etc. I’m biased. But my grandfather William Leonard aka 'Bulla', was the king, the grandmaster of storytelling. One of his best works, his best pearl, was that he sat on Salt Island Bay on a cloudy day and looked towards Red Bay, East End, Tortola, a distance of approximately 3.5 miles, and he could clearly see a mosquito picking a sandfly out of a hole. That was 20/20 vision.

30 Responses to “Salt Island: The Forgotten & Neglected Island- Part 2 of 3”

  • Florida Salt Connection Roll Call (05/11/2021, 16:00) Like (0) Dislike (3) Reply
    Excellent read cuz. But I must take you task on our ancestors having an idyllic life. No, life was not well and hard as well. I go in a frenzy without electricity for an hour. But Salt Island had no electricity, running water, indoor plumbing, telephones, cars….etc. I loved my creature comforts. How did they do it? They lived an unimaginable life and feel their misery perhaps.
  • Salt Island Subtract (05/11/2021, 18:16) Like (4) Dislike (0) Reply
    Edgar, thanks for highlighting and bringing the experience of the Salt Island people on the radar screen, putting a face on Salt Island people. Salt Islanders are true Virgin Islanders but were not always recognized and treated equally as other Virgin Islanders. They were stigmatized as Cay people(Edgar prefers the term Key; that works for me too. Parts 1 and 2 were informative, looking forward to Part 3.
  • Non-Salt Islander (05/11/2021, 20:44) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    As a mother, I was a moved by the emotional distress and sadness that mothers must have endured and experienced, seeing their son or daughter go off to school and only seeing and interacting with the child only infrequently at that. That was sad and painful for the parents. I don’t know or want to know everything my children are doing but I chat with them daily and they better answer when I call. Lol. I’m curious about the psychological impact, if any, on the children with the separation from their parents. How did the separation affect, if any, siblings relationship latter in life. Edgar, it appears as if you had that life experience so how was it? Agree with Florida Salt Connection Roll Call that life on Salt Island was hard as hell.
    • Me Too (06/11/2021, 10:47) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
      @Non-Salt Islander, me took as a mother feel the pain and emotional distress of those parents having to ship their 4- and 5-year olds off, not knowing when they will see them again. I’m a Virgin Islander but I was not aware of the life experiences my brethren on Salt Island. It seems like a social issue in the VI backyard that may have flew under the radar. Another blogger Salt Island Subtract 2 noted that government should issue an apology. I endorse that notion and add it should be a heartfelt and genuine apology. If no, why bother. An apology is not enough though; it is just words.
    • E. Leonard (06/11/2021, 11:23) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      @Non-Islander, thanks for your feedback. Salt Island is my ancestral homeland. Nonetheless, I was born on Cooper Island, Salt Island northeasterly neighbor, and spent my early childhood years on Cooper; visited and know a little about Salt Island.

      Like Salt Islanders, Cooper Islanders 3-, 4- and 5-year olds too was shipped to school to either Tortola or Anegada. My parents Cornelius and Maria Leonard too stood teary-eyed and emotional on Crawl Bay watching their children sail off to school. Both Salt Islanders and Cooper Islanders share similar experiences. I was fortunate (nuff respect and thumbs up to guardians) to return to Cooper when school was closed, spending time with my parents and younger siblings. That time home also entailed spending time on Salt with my father.
      • @E. Leonard (06/11/2021, 21:34) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
        Another Non-Islander, I’m trying to wrap my head around having to send a 3- and 4-year and even a 5-year old off to live with basically strangers to attend school. I’m not knocking the guardians who were taking the children in but the process itself. The disturbing part to me is that it appears that some young children only saw their parents only infrequently after going off to school. That is difficult for me to fathom. There must be something deeper here. What is up with this? I went to school with people from Salt Island and had no clue about their situation. I don’t know what E. Leonard intent was. Nevertheless, this was an illuminating article. The family separation issue was worth the monkey, the read. Admittedly, I did not read Part 1 but Part 2 motivated me to read Part 1. Just anticipating wondering what Part 3 is about. By the way E. Leonard, your grandfather William Leonard aka Bulla was a funny, humorous guy. Was your brother William who I have not seen in years named after him? Last point, I know you as a quiet guy but now you are a warrior. Lol.
      • Mother’s Love/Pain (07/11/2021, 19:17) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
        @E. Leonard, did you truly mean 3, 4 and 5 year old? Those are just babies. It is in the past but heart ache for the parents and both the children, for even if the guards were family, they are in essence strangers. The emotional pain those parents had to endure is unimaginable. Today, we can communicate with children with email, text, telephone/facetime, WhatsApp etc. Back then, they didn’t even have landlines. All I can say is wow!
  • Salt Island Subtract 2 (05/11/2021, 21:35) Like (4) Dislike (0) Reply
    Cuz, after reading Part 1, I thought there was not much more to say about living on Salt Island. But I’m delighted that there is more illuminating information on my ancestors life and living on Salt Island. I can only now imagine the emotional pain and stress my relatives must felt sending their young 4 or 5 old off to live with strangers. They mentally, physically and emotionally strong. Though being concerned at this point is going to matter, I’m curious as to why these children had to leave their parents at such a tender age. The VI was a presidency under the Leeward Island Federation, the VI was a colony of England, and there a local government so what did these entities do about this situation, if anything? Other than the parents, did anyone give a damn? People from the Southern Cays need an apology from government for the neglect and harmful treatment.
    • Culture of Dependency (06/11/2021, 15:58) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      There is a culture of dependency in the BVI. The populace is too dependent of government. What did government, why should it apologize and to whom should it apologize? Are not all the people that was supposedly injured dead. Yes, the people of Salt Island may have been treated unfairly and inequitably but so have other communities in the BVI. I’m from the country and country was treated as second class citizens. We lived through the stigma and now country is the location of choice to live. I’m not piling on Salt Island just asking question.
  • Salt Descendant 1 (05/11/2021, 22:25) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    Storytelling is an African tradition; the storyteller is called a Griot. Cuz William Leonard aka Bulla seemed to be one of the Salt Island. He had jokes. I liked the mosquito and sandfly tale; fast-forwarding, today he would be a hit as a comedian. I can imagine other islanders gathering around as he told stories to pass the time. Wish more of these stories, in fact, more of the history was documented. Thankful though and appreciate that an effort is being made to collect and share some information before all our remaining knowledgeable family is around. We have lost the opportunity to collect and document much information from older relatives and other residents who have been called home to rest.
  • NY SI Subtract Roll Call (06/11/2021, 10:09) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    Time for roll call meh son. Speak up and speak out and let your voices be heard. Our ancestors did not have the voice and opportunity we have. Our ancestors had a hard life. But they had the strength to persevere and survive. Yet there is barely any documentation of their existence. Mr. Leonard give us a glimpse of what their life was about. Respect!!! Nonetheless, there are lots of questions but probably no clear answers, ie, psychosexual terror, force labour exploitation, brutality, economic, emotional and social dependency etc. This generation has an obligation to document as much as it practical can for the benefit for the next generation. Salt Islanders, government, private sector etc must partner to make this happen. Let’s keep the roll call going.
  • Bell Vue Salt Island Connection (06/11/2021, 12:56) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    Bell Vue too is joining the Salt Island roll call. As a subtract of the Jennings from Bell Vue, support my Salt Island cuzs. The family separation experience must have poignant for family and children.
  • Anegada Roll Call (06/11/2021, 13:07) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    Anegada Salt Island subtract fam give a shout out to Salt Island family---Abbott connection. Check us at the November 26-28 Lobster Fest.
  • Rock Roll Call (06/11/2021, 13:16) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Rock (St. Thomas) Salt Island descendant joining the roll call parade. Looking forward to visiting Salt Island on the next descendant day celebration. Can the Salt Breaking event be revived and bacchanal started.
  • East End Roll Call (06/11/2021, 16:13) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Many families in East End are closely linked to Salt Island families. Many Salt Island children have attended school in East End, ie, the East End Methodist Church School and then Major Bay Primary now Williard Wheatley; parents have bawled plenty on the Bay watching chiren go off to school in East End. Bull thanks for the reminder of how life on the Cay was. Parents and grandparents suffered much to get their chiren an education. East End celebrate the roll call.
  • Spanish Town VG Roll Call (06/11/2021, 16:40) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Spanish Town, VG join the roll call to celebrate Salt Island ancestors. ✌️
  • Political Representation (06/11/2021, 18:26) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    Clearly, the people of Salt Island was at a distinct disadvantage, treated unfairly and inequality either deliberatively or inadvertently. In either case, they were wronged and suffered a social disparity based on geography; they were “Cay” people. They were treated as some external group living on an outlying island and not equally as other Virgin Islanders.

    Was it that their only value was picking salt, catching fish, catching goats etc to meet the need of Town people?

    Salt Island and other Southern Cays must have been in some political district. Were their basic needs just simply overlooked because of the social class the elites fling them into. Did their political representative failed miserably to fully represent them? Salt Islanders were a reserve people and just suffered through the indignities, miseries…..etc. Then who would they complain to redress their treatment? No one. Nonetheless, many of their descendants have contributed to the growth and development of the BVI. Many were conditioned not indicate that they had any Cay connection. But all you got to do is shake the family tree and see what falls out. With changing generations, the stigma of being from or being related to Cay folks is waining but it still lingers.
  • Road Town Roll Call (06/11/2021, 19:26) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    Road Town, the BVI capital city,Salt Island posse join the roll call and
  • Native Salt Islander (07/11/2021, 09:21) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Edgar, you forget to mention that they use to call Salt Island people “ Cay Goats.” When you little you brush it off but when you grow up you realized it was belittling. It hurts. But reading about Salt Island now is like therapy. Difficult to explain.
    • E. Leonard (07/11/2021, 14:10) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
      @Native Salt Islander, tru dat. Some people use the negative term just as follow fashion while others were invested in using it. Here is a true story. The setting is in Long Look-East End community. Two young ladies, one from East End-Long Look community and the other from the Cay, got in a scuffle at school. The young lady from the Cay won the scuffle that day. At home though, the young lady from the Long Look-East End community got more licks. She didn’t get more licks for losing the fight but for letting the Cay Goat beat her. I’m a proud and unapologetic ‘Key Boi’ but have much love for the East End-Long Look community; thumbs up to the Jimmy Young enclave. Grab a copy of Dr. Charles H. Wheatley latest book: Heritage and Hope: Finding my purpose in Virgin Islands Culture 1938-1963. It is a powerful read.
      • Seriously (07/11/2021, 19:42) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
        Someone getting licks at home because she lost a school yard fight to supposedly a ‘Cay Goat’ is hard to fathom. Who could be this silly. I can see getting a cutass for fighting. Is this Cay Goat thing real?
        • E.Leonard (07/11/2021, 21:38) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
          @Seriously, it seems as if there is some doubt as to the authenticity of the offensive term ‘Key Goat’ and its indignities. Lots of questions have arisen. Have responded to a few others and will respond to this one. The term Key Goat is real, not imagined. Post slavery, the VI society shifted from a primarily racist society (master-slave) towards social stratification, classist society. People from the ‘Key’ were at bottom of the social ladder. In ascending order, the social ladder was Key people, larger outlying islands, country(areas outside of Road Town proper), Up Street, & Down Street. And within these major groupings, are subgroupings. In this pepper pot, I will add the terms Above Round Rock, and Down Island. Being at the bottom of the social ladder came with much socioeconomic disadvantages, inequities etc. Nonetheless, the society was socially stratified but the lines are blurring.
  • Ne Timeas (07/11/2021, 16:14) Like (2) Dislike (1) Reply
    This is a melancholic, bittersweet, ambivalent etc real life story that occurred in the BVI backyard. Well, not in the backyard, for it happened to fellow Virgin Islanders. And this is probably just the tip of iceberg. Perhaps an apology should extend to the people/descendants of Salt Island. Some may argue that an apology will open the floodgate. Well, just apologize to all the communities that may have been discriminated against. No need to pretend and be afraid about the truth, about history. That pretending about history is US thing.
  • Real Florida Roll Call (07/11/2021, 23:57) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    Florida, the Sun Shine State, join the Salt Island roll call celebration. Shout out to the FAMU Rattlers. Like the FAMU Rattlers, a united Salt Island descendants must strike, strike and strike again for Salt Island to rise like a Phoenix from its decline. Let’s revive and enlighten its rich history and proud heritage.
  • Social Scientist (08/11/2021, 12:00) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    I read this commentary with both alarm and interest. It peek my interest. From a far, it seems that parents noble and responsible actions in getting their children a basic education may have resulted their losing some of them. It was/is, perhaps, a journey/saga of the lost children. It is a great story for a fascinating case study. A great thesis for an aspiring doctoral student. There is much here to work with, ie, hardships, torments, joy, pain, triumphs, successes….etc. Someone can and should write a master piece on the life and times of the Salt Island people.

    Leonard’s commentary was I’m assuming just the tip of the ice-burg; beneath the surface must be much more. The late John Lewis, civil rights icon, implored us to get in trouble, good trouble. Though I don’t profess to know what was Leonard purpose (perhaps he can elaborate) was, regardless of his intent, it in my opinion tore the scab off a wound but it seems as good scab to tear off a quiet wound that may bring some closure perhaps. Any thoughts/feedback. Social scientists adore feedback.
  • Old & Settled Issue (08/11/2021, 17:28) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    The people of Salt Island and the other Southern Cays were treated poorly and inequitably. It is not a current issue; it is an old and settled issue. What is the purpose of digging up this issue now? It only creates animosity and division in the community that now has more critical issues facing it. The parents who were wronged are long gone and no action taken will make them whole. To me, it best to move on and let sleeping dogs lie and look towards the future. The descendants of Salt Island didn’t do so badly, for many have and are contributing to the developing of the BVI community. E. Leonard, the writer of the commentary, I personally know was educated in the BVI public school system and I’m sure he will take issue with my comment. It is time to move forward and get on with our lives.
    • E. Leonard (08/11/2021, 19:55) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
      @Old and Settled Issue, the issue may be old but it is not settled, though it is not often publicly discussed. You are entitled to your position and opinion. Nonetheless, I cannot and will not let the issue be swift-boated (true this term is often used in a political context). We are proud of and celebrate the success of the Salt Island descendants. However, neither their success nor my attending public school bares little to no relevance to the the inequitable core issues, ie, impact of family separation etc.

      Moreover, you posited that we should move on. With this attitude, I’m assuming that you are not a Salt Island descendant, for he/she who or whose family lived it knows and feels it. Should the 6,000, 000+ Jews slaughtered/descendants in the Holocaust or the Japanese survivors/descendants interned by the US during WWII or exploited Native/indigenous Americans or the exploited Australian aborigines or the Kenyan Mau Mau just move on?

      Further, should the descendants of Slaves who were dehumanized, brutalized, exploited etc move on? No. To the fullest extent practical and possible, they should be made whole. True, it may not be fair to compare the Salt Island people experience to the horrific scale of the foregoing events.
      • Old and Settled Issue (09/11/2021, 08:23) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
        Good points and got it. But you still have not outlined what you want for Salt Island people descendants. Swift-boated! You ain’t easy meh son.
  • E. Leonard (09/11/2021, 10:18) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    @Old and Settled Issue. I’m not looking for anything less for the Salt Island community than is/have been afforded to other VI communities. First, the hope is that the history and heritage of Salt Island and its people is not forgotten and lost and that generations of Salt Island descendants would be aware of life and living on their ancestral homeland. Second, Salt Island receive close up representation, fair and equitable treatment, and fair and equitable distribution of available budgetary resources. And third, recognition of the Salt Island people experience and inequitable treatment so as to attempt to bring closure.


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.