Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

The Baths controversy ‘far from over'- Sharon P. Flax-Brutus

- calls for government transparency
According to JTV Channel 55, Community advocate and businesswoman Sharon P. Flax-Brutus is demanding that elected officials formally declare their positions on the matter. Photo: VINO/File
Community advocate and businesswoman Sharon P. Flax-Brutus asserts that the controversy surrounding proposed exclusive access at The Baths is far from over, even as talks on the arrangement have been temporarily halted. Photo: Facebook
Community advocate and businesswoman Sharon P. Flax-Brutus asserts that the controversy surrounding proposed exclusive access at The Baths is far from over, even as talks on the arrangement have been temporarily halted. Photo: Facebook
The National Parks Trust recently paused negotiations regarding an exclusive-access model following a directive from Deputy Premier and Minister responsible for the Trust, Honourable Julian Fraser RA (R3), pending further government review. Photo: Facebook
The National Parks Trust recently paused negotiations regarding an exclusive-access model following a directive from Deputy Premier and Minister responsible for the Trust, Honourable Julian Fraser RA (R3), pending further government review. Photo: Facebook
VALLEY, Virgin Gorda, VI- Community advocate and businesswoman Sharon P. Flax-Brutus asserts that the controversy surrounding proposed exclusive access to The Baths is far from over, even as talks on the arrangement have been temporarily halted.

According to JTV Channel 55, Flax-Brutus is demanding that elected officials formally declare their positions on the matter.

The National Parks Trust recently paused negotiations regarding an exclusive-access model following a directive from Deputy Premier and Minister responsible for the Trust, Honourable Julian Fraser RA (R3), pending further government review.

Scrutiny over process & leadership

Following a recent virtual community meeting, Flax-Brutus commended the National Parks Trust for creating a forum for dialogue. However, she emphasised that the session generated as many questions as answers, particularly concerning revenue generation, legal authority, carrying capacity, and proposed rest days.

JTV Channel 55 reported that Flax-Brutus also criticised the format of the meeting, noting that technical difficulties raised doubts about whether every resident could participate fully. She specifically challenged the silence of key public bodies and elected officials.

The former Director of Tourism demanded clarity on the stances of the Premier, the Ministry of Tourism, the BVI Tourist Board, and the BVI Ports Authority. She questioned whether these key tourism and maritime entities were consulted as cruise industry negotiations advanced and also expressed concern over elected representatives remaining on the sidelines while residents were left to steer the debate.

Preserving Heritage and Public Access

Flax-Brutus described the world-renowned site as an essential part of Virgin Gorda’s identity, economy, history, and inheritance rather than a mere commercial attraction. She stressed that public access and capacity management should never be settled behind closed doors or presented to the public only after commercial terms have advanced. 

The public response, she noted, proves that management of the site is an issue of national significance across the entire Territory.

Calls for Transparency and In-Person Dialogue

Moving forward, Flax-Brutus is demanding full transparency and direct engagement from territorial leadership before any policy changes are finalised. She added that there should be an explicit public declaration from every elected member of the House of Assembly stating whether they support or oppose exclusive access, a properly advertised, in-person public meeting on Virgin Gorda with a hybrid virtual component for broader access, and the immediate public release of all capacity assessments, relevant studies, draft agreements, and legal advice.

While affirming support for sustainable revenue generation, environmental protection, and sound capacity management, JTV Channel 55 stated that Flax-Brutus remains opposed to granting exclusive access to any private entity. She maintains that no rest dates, capacity limits, or exclusivity agreements should take effect without independent assessments and genuine public consultation, noting that recent discussions represent only the beginning of the debate.

Meanwhile, Ninth District Representative and Minister for Health and Social Development Hon Vincent O. Wheatley (R9) has already strongly expressed that The Baths and Devil’s Bay must remain open and accessible to the public without exclusion or preference to any single commercial interest.

See related articles below:

The Baths & Devil’s Bay 'must remain open' to the public- Hon Vincent O. Wheatley

Public outcry over proposed exclusive cruise access to The Baths & Devil’s Bay

 

 

 

17 Responses to “The Baths controversy ‘far from over'- Sharon P. Flax-Brutus ”

  • WHAT!!! (31/08/2026, 11:37) Like (20) Dislike (1) Reply
    “Full transparency “ from our present vip leader and government, one word impossible .
  • Hmmm. (31/08/2026, 12:11) Like (10) Dislike (5) Reply
    People she and her sister are gearing to run for next election. They’ve created a chat in VG that they control and running a quasi government they undermine Vincent every chance they get. Thank god he’s smart enough to not fall for their traps.
    • you got that right!! (31/08/2026, 13:38) Like (3) Dislike (3) Reply
      Notice how these supposedly courageous voices have carefully avoided one obvious question: Where does the Minister for Natural Resources stand?The article demands clarity from the Premier, Tourism Ministry, Tourist Board and Ports Authority—yet somehow the Minister for Natural Resources escapes even a mention.Apparently, courage is plentiful when aimed at someone perceived as vulnerable, but suddenly becomes scarce when it requires confronting the powerful.And this is not an isolated case. Another aspiring politician with an online platform, who routinely boasts about challenging the status quo, hasn't said a peep about the Minister either.If you cannot summon the courage to ask those in power a simple question before being elected, why should anyone believe you will suddenly find that courage after you are elected?Selective courage is not courage. Selective accountability is not accountability.Thank God people like Hmmm have their eyes open. Unfortunately, too many still don't.
  • Brutus (31/08/2026, 12:24) Like (8) Dislike (7) Reply
    If there is no flax in this deal to be woven, then we are not in support.
  • Wellsah (31/08/2026, 12:44) Like (2) Dislike (9) Reply
    listen the rich people on Four Seasons yacht are looking for a bespoke experience that the brokies on the mass marketed cruise lines cant easily obtain they have thousands of other islands and cays in the Caribbean to choose from so we should be grateful they are considering us
    • @wellsah (31/08/2026, 14:44) Like (2) Dislike (6) Reply
      The tourists arriving on Norwegian, Disney, Celebrity, Aida etc. are not broke people! You would find more run of the mill people on Carnival and some Euro Lines, which we get a hand full, but quite a few of the people arriving on the higher end lines can afford to visit the BVI as an overnight or charter guest and many do. The whole fight against cruise tourism is being pushed by those who cannot find a way to make money off it so therefore it's bad.
  • Ms brutus (31/08/2026, 13:42) Like (9) Dislike (6) Reply
    You will not win an election... find something better to.do. if you did something good before show it. If none go sit down and not lookibg for mistake that you also has no meaningful solution.

    Chatgpt is free if that can help you.. $20 if you need more information


  • BRAD BOYNES (31/08/2026, 14:27) Like (28) Dislike (0) Reply
    "She stressed that public access and capacity management should never be settled behind closed doors or presented to the public only after commercial terms have advanced".

    That is tantamount to what Kedrick Pickering said some years ago when he let the whole VI and the world know that "quote.. That's a done deal" on the expansion of the airport at the time. But Kedrick was talking with three tongues.
    • Worth a try. (31/08/2026, 15:40) Like (0) Dislike (5) Reply
      Can't failed something without giving it a chance to fail...This will need some compromising...I like the Idea of exclusive cruise access half days Monday to Friday only... That's a workable and beneficial schedule for all.
  • north sound (31/08/2026, 15:48) Like (9) Dislike (1) Reply
    She wid her tired political ambitions
  • quiet (31/08/2026, 16:28) Like (12) Dislike (3) Reply
    The reason that so few public officials haven't spoken about it is that they very quietly want it to work out. They're okay with selling out the country.

    Speaking up in support of it is poison, no one actually wants their name closely associated with selling out the country to tourists. Instead, they just won't say anything, then in a few years when it becomes clear that it was a massive mistake they can talk about it as if they didn't have the chance to speak out against it.

    Think about it. This is an election year. If I was running, I would be screaming from the rooftops that I am against this, because it's easy points to score. But they're not. And it's not because its Virgin Gorda, you give a beach to someone on Virgin Gorda, then they're going to ask for beaches on Jost Van Dyke, and then Tortola. They know the issue will eventually spread. They don't care. I wouldn't be suprise if some of them got an extra wire at the bank to make sure too. We don't have that many elected officials. It's easier for these rich foreign companies to buy them out.
  • Cindy (31/08/2026, 17:17) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    them flax sisters have to understand is not everything is politics
    • Political clout chasing (31/08/2026, 20:28) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      They will milk anything that they believe willl get political traction but the people are not stupid.
  • Judy (31/08/2026, 18:38) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    let the games begin
  • Don't believe the hype! (01/09/2026, 09:37) Like (3) Dislike (0) Reply
    The both of these sisters have political aspirations and using this issue as a way to keep themselves in the media! Vincent and Fraser playing politics and the rest of us looking like a bunch of dummies!

    During the Zoom meeting, the gentleman said that the Trust DID come to VG and inform them that they were planning to do this deal! It's recorded! NOBODY OBJECTED!

    It's now talking season. All of a sudden, Shereen who was all for the luxury cruise lines being integrated in local tourism as a VIP member doesn't want the deal done! She have to be seen and heard now!

    Then we have Sharon! Everyday she working hard to selling beachfront land on Virgin Gorda as a Sotheby Real Estate agent! Land that you can't access and when you do, them chasing you off of! Now all of a sudden, VG is for Virgin Gordians! People wake up! Do you realize how diabolical it is for you to be selling VG from underneath it's people, while advocating for resident access to all of the BVI?

    Then there's Vincent! He sooo happy that it have a crisis on VG. He throw on a cape to come save the day with his false concern! The Same Vincent who's lack of action causing I'll people to pass and also giving away land left and right in VG all of a sudden is concerned for VG residents?

    Let's not talk about Fraser! The gentleman told everyone that Fraser supported everything that they were doing! All of a sudden, he thinking bout reelection, he against the move!

    This is all political theater! Actors on the stage named the BVI.
  • Black Lives Matter (01/09/2026, 09:45) Like (2) Dislike (1) Reply
    Sharon P. Flax-Brutus Is just another angry black women
  • BRAD BOYNES (01/09/2026, 14:59) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    There should be no controversy with this.


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.
Video Ad


Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.