Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

‘Some businesses feel workers should just be glad they have a job’- Cromwell Smith

- said there needs to be a balance where more value is placed on the employee
Talk show host Cromwell Smith aka Edju En Ka believes that when considering what the minimum wage should be like, more value needs to be placed on the employer as he gets the feeling more of the emphasis is often given to the employer. Photo: VINO/File
The topic on Umoja aired March 18, 2024, was Minimum Wage & Quality of Life and included co-host Shaina M. Smith-Archer and Policy Analyst II in the Ministry of Financial Services, Trade and Labour Dr Dawn Alexander-Joseph. Photo: Facebook
The topic on Umoja aired March 18, 2024, was Minimum Wage & Quality of Life and included co-host Shaina M. Smith-Archer and Policy Analyst II in the Ministry of Financial Services, Trade and Labour Dr Dawn Alexander-Joseph. Photo: Facebook
BAUGHERS BAY, Tortola, VI- Talk show host Cromwell Smith aka Edju En Ka believes that when considering what the minimum wage should be like, more value needs to be placed on the employer as he gets the feeling more of the emphasis is often given to the employer.

“I think the emphasis seems to me to be on the cost of doing business in the territory, and not as much the cost of living in the territory, and that’s a concern that I have,” Mr Smith stated on Umoja aired on ZBVI 780 AM on March 18, 2024.

The topic at the time was Minimum Wage & Quality of Life and included co-host Shaina M. Smith-Archer and Policy Analyst II in the Ministry of Financial Services, Trade and Labour Dr Dawn Alexander-Joseph.

“Because you see workers struggling to make ends meet, struggling to support their families, but then you see businesses making profits that allows them to have an excellent quality of life, an above average quality of life…buying some of the most expensive things and going on the most expensive vacations and have this quality of life that workers only marvel at, could dream about,” Mr Smith continued.

‘Balance’ needed

The talk show host said he understands that an investment has been made but he gets the feeling that businesses feel workers should be glad that they have a job and so they don’t pay them more even when they can afford to.

Mr Smith said perhaps that thinking needs to “even out”, as workers are important too and they have responsibilities as well.

Mrs Smith, who is also the Chairperson of the BVI Chamber of Commerce, said while she agrees there should be a “balance”, she said sometimes businesses are unfairly referred to as a non-human entity but they have owners and businesses sometimes have to take risks.

She also agreed there may be cases where employers are abusing employees, meaning they are taking advantage of them when they can afford to pay more but are not because they are maximising profits.

“But I can’t allow persons to feel that is a generalisation across the board and that all businesses behave like that, because during the pandemic there were a lot of businesses that could not afford to keep their employees but because they understood that if they sent them home they would have no income whatsoever.”

It was announced in November 2023, that the Ministry of Financial Services, Labour and Trade had established an ad hoc advisory committee to review the minimum wage in the Virgin Islands and report by the end of March 2024.

The minimum wage in the Virgin Islands was last increased on October 1, 2016, from $4.00 per hour to $6.00 per hour.

28 Responses to “‘Some businesses feel workers should just be glad they have a job’- Cromwell Smith”

  • jokes (19/03/2024, 15:07) Like (26) Dislike (5) Reply
    How can there be a balance? If there is no business, there no job. If it costs too much to run the business, the business closes, the owner finds alternative and the employees are up in the air with nothing to do. I am not sure why people act as if business and making money is some kind of magic. The issue in the BVI currently is that the economy is down and nothing is being done to change that. We have been in a downward spiral since Irma 7 years ago and everyone thought that praying and hoping would make things better. Here we are now talking about increasing wages in a horrible economy and making it seem as if business owners are devils. Are some business people nasty and treat staff bad? Of course! But any sensible business person understands that their greatest asset is their human resources so I would say a lot of businesses treat their employees decent. Cromwell is here saying cost of living is more important than cost of doing business. WTF? If the cost of doing business isn't addressed then don't you expect the cost of living to increase? Businesses have a slow economy, NHI, SSB, Taxes, Duties, Rent, Insurance, Cost of Goods, Wages, Maintenance. If Cromwell ever had a real business he wouldn't be spewing such socialist nonsense.
    • Notice to Employees for Employers (20/03/2024, 07:48) Like (8) Dislike (9) Reply
      If you don’t like working here then you can go and work somewhere else. The end.
  • Wicked employers. (19/03/2024, 15:46) Like (13) Dislike (6) Reply
    Once these employers can make share holders money on the back of the employees and look good in the Eyes of share holders, they getting big bonuses while employers struggling to live...Lorna is a big Joke. She promise to have the minimum wage report by March, its now March. Whats up with the Report Lorna..I hope its not 8 or 9 dollars,. No one should be going home with less than $400 per week after tax...minimum wage should be minimum $11.00.per hr.
  • The Lodge. (19/03/2024, 15:51) Like (15) Dislike (3) Reply
    That Satanic club run Tortola. Them wicked and selfish as hell. Poor people can starv and dead for them..
  • kk (19/03/2024, 15:53) Like (2) Dislike (3) Reply
    So true my brother
  • omg (19/03/2024, 16:11) Like (23) Dislike (0) Reply
    Omg $6 an hr and rent it $8-$1200 a month for a one bedroom and food plus utility how can a man buy condoms or a woman soaps
  • Celestina (19/03/2024, 16:53) Like (5) Dislike (5) Reply
    At Conyers
    • @Celestina (20/03/2024, 20:45) Like (5) Dislike (1) Reply
      That old lady need to leave that company. Been hell ever since she got the job.
      • Jobless (21/03/2024, 09:12) Like (2) Dislike (3) Reply
        You can tell that a disgruntled employee made this comment, only a retard would reply to their own post...you can tell you are unprofessional and uneducated and this is why you will not grow, appreciate that you have a job fool.
  • smh (19/03/2024, 16:55) Like (7) Dislike (15) Reply
    This guy seems to be far off the mark, you should not be speaking for businesses Cromwell. Just go sit back down.
  • USED (19/03/2024, 17:00) Like (12) Dislike (0) Reply
    A lot of businesses are using and abusing their workers. Some taking out there monetary deductions and contributions and are not paying it into the relevant department. Some making them work overtime and not paying the employees. Some are not paying salary period or owing their workers for weeks and months. As though employees can take that to the supermarkets, doctors, landlords, electricity, phone companies, water companies, clothing store, pharmacies, schools, bus drivers, hairdressers you name it they can't because some of these so call businesses here fronting to say they have businesses and they are a big failure.
    If you learn to be true to self close the businesses if you find you can't continue and stop conning your employees who are suffering under your hands. You to prideful don't want people to see you had to close the business so ashamed. Family or friend or who ever working for you needs money to survive stop being selfish. Leave people alone if you cant afford to hire people and stop creating fake jobs to get people into the territory. What is the real motive behind some of these businesses bringing in workers or using the locals should be the real question. You broke shut shop simple stop faking it.
    • Norris Turnbull (20/03/2024, 07:13) Like (3) Dislike (7) Reply
      A lot of workers abuse their employer also. Talk that part also.
  • Employees VS Employer (19/03/2024, 18:26) Like (13) Dislike (0) Reply
    Tell the employers, that without the Employees, they will have nothing more than empty office and or stores, or wherever businesses is been operated. The slave masters use to feel the same, that slaves were dogs. What’s different today? Some businesses owners failed, and some is failing as I write, because they treat their employees bad, the employees turn around and treat customers the way they are treated. None of those business owners can live off of today’s minimum wages. NONE. Some employers steal employees SS money, due to the Government, for later retirement. Some short pay, won’t overtime pay, insurance and more. That kind of treatment from employers set up employees to steal and sabotage the business. No company or business survives too long without well treated employees. You employers, yes employees need you, just like you need them to get rich, don’t get too cocky, always remember who build you up. Take care of your employees properly, they in turn will take care of your business and customers. Show appreciation, thank, REWARD and RESPECT employees. You will be the winner, but don’t try to rob them a $ here and there. Many Employers are like BAD LANDLORDS, want big money for apartment/houses, but don’t want to fixed their own place, when their is a problem, THAT IS THEIR PERSONALITY.
  • See (19/03/2024, 19:39) Like (15) Dislike (0) Reply
    We seem good at talking about slavery and how bad the slave masters were but currently the territory operates on a modified slavery system . That's the way it is here be honest with yourselves. Sad to work hard and still not have the essentials being met
  • Winky (19/03/2024, 20:33) Like (5) Dislike (3) Reply
    Simple.... if you don't like your job leave. this place has screwed things up so badly that businesses are struggling to survive.
    • @Winky (19/03/2024, 23:33) Like (0) Dislike (1) Reply
      We like to cast blame on everyone else and don't examine our selves. Sometimes and most times we have selfish employers who would make the money but them wicked they prefer to spend ot on woman and man to try to keep them and travel the world dressed to try to impress yet they hungry and got to go beg and borrow money or con people trying to be sweet yet they got to borrow from family and friends to go pay hefty electricity Bill's etc. Wicked wicked wicked
    • @ Winky. Get real. (20/03/2024, 05:36) Like (4) Dislike (1) Reply
      Some employees are useless, very indisciplined, no effort, add no value to the company, they are only there because of the money, they have favour with the boss os the are from here...We have hard working employees with much added Value that are being over looked, So, the challenge for a business will be ok. Have no problem paying these hard working set 11.00 per hr, but will not and cannot pay that set $11.00 per hr. But now they are forced to do that and they are forced to keep them....So the good employees suffer for the bad.. What the solution for that situation?
  • @ USED (19/03/2024, 21:59) Like (1) Dislike (7) Reply
    WHO WOULD KNOW MORE ABOUT THAT THAN THE CHICKEN HAWK FROM VG WHO WAS SCOOPING PEOPLE WHO WORKED HONESTLY TO MAKE A LIVING TO SEE HOW THEY SPEND IT AND GET TOGETHER WITH THE HEAD COACH AND COME UP WITH AN EVIL IDEA ON HOW TO DOUBLE TAX THE ISLAND PEOPLE AS WE CALL THEM , WHILE THEY CLOSED THEIR EYES AT THE EMPLOYERS WHO IS TAKING OUT THEIR TAXES ALREADY AND NOT PAYING THEIR FAIR SHARE OF TAXES TO THE SAME GOVERNMENT THAT THEY ARE IN CONTROL OF * UNTOUCHED * WELL THE LORD TOUCHED THE COACH SO HIS TURN NEXT ( HOW CAN SOME PEOPLE BE SO MEAN TO OTHER PEOPLE JUST BECAUSE YOU GOT A LITTLE POWER AT THEIR DISPOSAL ❓️????
    • Discredited (20/03/2024, 08:31) Like (2) Dislike (1) Reply
      whatever your personal agenda is with the 9th District rep you need to take it up with him. You act as though he was the one that came up with the idea of taxing western uion and he alone executed it. sme of the same others who voted for it you dont seem to have a problem with, You are a hypocrite. If you have a problem with the bill them give the blame equally if not then you are nothing but a coward,
  • Penny wize pound foolish (20/03/2024, 02:41) Like (7) Dislike (2) Reply
    Businesses in the BVI do not employ locals they employ expat because expat will work for less and they can take advantage of them. If locals are not gainfully employed they won't have money to spend back into the economy. The majority of the expat money goes out to build their country.
    • Who fool u (21/03/2024, 09:42) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      What can u use to send back and build ur country. The most u can send is to help feed ur family nothing much more than that. After you pay rent there's not much more you can do. Buying groceries here is like being on ur calculator crunching numbers daily shifting around on your budget to see how you can manage. Many people on minimum wage cannot afford what you hinting at. Those you seeing at the money transfer aren't minimum workers and they aren't sending more than 200 to their respective countries monthly.
  • HMMM (20/03/2024, 06:43) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    Department Of Agriculture and Fisheries
  • @Pennywise (20/03/2024, 07:31) Like (5) Dislike (2) Reply
    There is not a single.local that wants a job and cannot find one. The issue is many want a certain job and would stay home until they get that specific job. Reading your post you can tell you never owned a business because if you think employing a skilled expat worker is cheap then think again!
  • ausar (20/03/2024, 09:58) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    I say, ten (10) USD an hour, as minimum wage!

    But, with all of you so, Ed Ju Enka, and the others, who seemingly have blocked the passages of such an increase, it cannot happen!

    That this discussion continues, ad nauseum, WITHOUT ACTION, says to me, that there is no real plan to implement such changes!

    It is bordering now, on feel good legislation, feel good discussions, to garner votes!

    TIME FOR ACTION, legislators!
    TIME FOR ACTION!

  • Real Talk (20/03/2024, 11:17) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply

    NOW IMAGINE THIS, THE OWNER FOR B*******Y HAD A YOUNG MAN WORKING FOR HIM AT NANNY CAY BOAT YARD FOR THE PAST FIVE (5) YEARS ON HOLIDAYS AND WEEK END THINGS GOT SLOW SO GUESS WHAT HE DID FIRED THE GUY ACCUSING OF STEALING FIVE YEARS REMBER GUESS WHAT NO VACATION FOR ALL THOSE YEARS OF WORKING NO OVER TIME PAY AND STILL CANT GET PAID AFTER HE FIRED HIM THESE EMPLOYERS NEED TO HANG IN PUBLIC NO SENSE GOING TO LABOUR WASTE OF TIME

  • Bush Professor (20/03/2024, 14:37) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    Yes, employers invest the capital and take the risks but unless it is a one man or woman show, a business needs employees to generate profit. And employees should reasonably share in the profits by earning a living wage. Supply and demand drive wages in the BVI. The supply of cheap labour exceeds the demand. Consequently, employers can pay lower rates for labor. Expat workers are more motivated for lower wages compared to locals and belongers. And in many cases they exploited and abused. Virgin Islanders behave like any other people in developing and emerging countries, ie, as the country standard of living and quality of life improves, locals shy away from certain jobs; it happens everywhere, ie, ie, US, Canada, UK, Middle East, USVI, Antigua, etc. and in the BVI no less, ie, sanitation, domestic work, other service jobs, etc. Pay the workers a living wage. We like to say workers are like family. Well, let’s not be hypocrites; treat them like families.
  • Hospital (20/03/2024, 18:57) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    That's how the lady at hospital behave.
  • @ EDU (21/03/2024, 08:19) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    Where were you living ? That has been the norm for decades , ah guess you miss the spotlight , go back in the closet untill you see all the corruption , guns , drugs killings etc and assist the police , that will be a good start to the cleansing of our once peaceful country , if you got the ballz


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.