‘Locking people up does not work’- UWI Professor Corin A. Bailey
Dr Bailey’s comments come as the Virgin Islands (VI) reflects on the recently held Restorative Justice and Pathways Conference, described as a milestone in advancing national conversations on justice, rehabilitation, and community restoration. The conference featured a discussion with Dr Bailey on the impact of restorative justice in the Territory and its wider role in shaping the future of justice.
He said the evidence shows that simply locking people away, with the assumption that they will return to society as “better versions of themselves,” does not work. Instead, he argued, early contact with the justice system can increase the likelihood that a person remains trapped in it for much of their life.
“The data, the statistics, the evidence show that locking people up, assuming that if it is that they are released, that they are better versions of themselves… is not the case,” he said. “As soon as someone comes into contact with the justice system, their chances of being embedded within that system for the rest of their lives increase exponentially.”
Recidivism remains high
Dr Bailey pointed to recent research across several Caribbean islands that found a 41 per cent recidivism rate, with a substantial number of people returning to prison within two years. He said those figures demonstrate that governments must acknowledge that current approaches are not delivering the results communities need.
The finding is consistent with earlier regional research presented by Dr Bailey, which reported that 41 percent of inmates surveyed across six Caribbean countries were recidivists.
Restorative justice as prevention
For Dr Bailey, restorative justice is one important part of a broader crime-prevention strategy. He argued that reducing the rapid escalation of crime in the region requires a holistic approach in which what happens after an arrest matters as much as the work done to prevent crime in the first place.
“I’m in the business of crime prevention, and I see restorative justice as one aspect of that,” he said. “What we do after apprehension is just as important as what we do before.”
Restorative justice typically brings affected parties together to address harm, accountability, repair, and reintegration, rather than relying solely on punishment and incarceration. This year’s international observance, held from November 15 to 21, highlights restorative justice’s potential to repair connections and rebuild communities.
A call to government
Dr Bailey urged more governments across the Caribbean to accept that the current model is not working and to embrace a different approach. He said restorative justice offers a pathway toward rehabilitation, stronger communities, and a justice system that addresses the causes and consequences of harm rather than simply responding to it after the fact.
As Restorative Justice Week continues, advocates say the challenge now is to move from discussion to durable policy: building programmes that give victims a meaningful voice, support accountability, and create realistic routes for people to reintegrate successfully after contact with the justice system.

Leave a Reply