Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

Court rocked by limited space, storage, money, old & crumbling buildings-Smith-Penn

- Offices of the Virgin Islands Judicial System working in deplorable conditions that make them sick, Commercial Court already out of space!
It was while testifying before the House of Assembly’s Standing Finance Committee in regards to the 2016 Budget that the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court, Mrs Erica Smith-Penn, made public the many other challenges facing the judicial system. Photo: VINO
Many of the court houses and office buildings used by the judicial system are already out of space, according to Mrs Smith-Penn who oversees the logistics for some forty two officers and a juridical team of four. The Registrar told the SFC that the Commercial Court had very little room for expansion and one Judicial Officer had to be moved to the Registry. The Registrar further advised that there was a continuous need for court space to hear matters and a conference room at the Registry had to be converted into a court room even though the funds to procure such things as furnishings were limited. Photo: VINO
Many of the court houses and office buildings used by the judicial system are already out of space, according to Mrs Smith-Penn who oversees the logistics for some forty two officers and a juridical team of four. The Registrar told the SFC that the Commercial Court had very little room for expansion and one Judicial Officer had to be moved to the Registry. The Registrar further advised that there was a continuous need for court space to hear matters and a conference room at the Registry had to be converted into a court room even though the funds to procure such things as furnishings were limited. Photo: VINO
Mrs Smith-Penn told the Standing Finance Committee (SFC) that some of the serious issues faced by the court system are lack of office/court room space, lack of storage space, insufficient budget for contributions to overseas organisations, electricity, building maintenance, personal emoluments and other operations expenditure and inadequate building facilities. Photo: VINO
Mrs Smith-Penn told the Standing Finance Committee (SFC) that some of the serious issues faced by the court system are lack of office/court room space, lack of storage space, insufficient budget for contributions to overseas organisations, electricity, building maintenance, personal emoluments and other operations expenditure and inadequate building facilities. Photo: VINO
ROAD TOWN, Tortola, VI- Beside many Virgin Islanders believing that the judicial system is just like the political system, allegedly corrupt and out of touch, there are other vexing issues faced daily by officers of the Legal system.

It was while testifying before the House of Assembly’s Standing Finance Committee in regards to the 2016 Budget that the Chief Registrar of the Supreme Court, Mrs Erica Smith-Penn, made public the many other challenges.

Mrs Smith-Penn told the Standing Finance Committee (SFC) that some of the serious issues faced by the court system are lack of office/court room space, lack of storage space, insufficient budget for contributions to overseas organisations, electricity, building maintenance, personal emoluments and other operations expenditure and inadequate building facilities.

No space; Commercial Court too small already

Many of the court houses and office buildings used by the judicial system are already out of space, according to Mrs Smith-Penn who oversees the logistics for some forty two officers and a juridical team of four. The Registrar told the SFC that the Commercial Court had very little room for expansion and one Judicial Officer had to be moved to the Registry.

The Registrar further advised that there was a continuous need for court space to hear matters and a conference room at the Registry had to be converted into a court room even though the funds to procure such things as furnishings were limited.

Mrs Smith-Penn complained that “an additional judge was appointed, but there was no space for him to be accommodated and one of the Deputy Registrars had to be displaced to provide seating arrangement as the current space configuration has been outgrown.” She also told law makers that she would welcome additional budget funds to reconfigure the space.

No storage for court documents

The Chief Registrar stated that when matters are filed they go to their archive facilities in Pockwood Pond on the main island of Tortola and because of lack of storage space it was a problem when searches had to be conducted as there were boxes lining the area which was not good for security and did not appeal to their appearance.

In her testimony Mrs Smith-Penn said she would like to “upgrade to a more user-friendly, modern facility outfitted with electronic searching, but was advised that it cannot accommodate the load as they expand.”

Insufficient Budget; VI behind in overseas contributions

The Registrar told the House committee that there continues to be insufficient funds for contributions to overseas organisations, electricity, building maintenance, paying staff and other operational expenditures.

Mrs Smith-Penn said the Virgin Islands is committed to overseas contributions in the amount of $727,000. However, she said the funds given to her “was insufficient” and she had to request additional funds to augment the budget as there was a shortfall for overseas contributions.

Inadequate building facilities

The challenges of the court system continue, including inadequate building facilities. The Registrar stated that the facilities housing the court officers in the 'Old Administration Building' “was beginning to crack and crumble and was falling apart.”

She told the SFC that she was “concerned for the staff, as the structural integrity and the air quality causes considerable expenditure.”

Mrs Smith-Penn noted that “it was a real issue as officers become sick and overall maintenance cost continue to dig into the Budget,” according to the SFC Report of 2016.

As of publication time, no comments were forth-coming from the Governor or Deputy Governor’s Offices who are responsible for the court system in the Virgin Islands.

13 Responses to “Court rocked by limited space, storage, money, old & crumbling buildings-Smith-Penn”

  • Bunny (08/04/2016, 15:56) Like (16) Dislike (2) Reply
    What a shame for a country bosting of a 330 Million dallor budget
    • Corrupt. Hmmm (08/04/2016, 19:07) Like (4) Dislike (2) Reply
      One thing for sure. Its more corrupt than politicians.. All She can talk about is spend, spend. We are in a system where the belief or mentality is that sending people to jail is success..(nonsense)., huge fine then deport and for those from here huge fine and long probation. Those make more sense. Help bring cash in.
      • @Corrupt. Hmmm (08/04/2016, 21:20) Like (3) Dislike (1) Reply
        Be careful that you and VINO don't find yall self before the same court for contempt!
        • @ you (08/04/2016, 23:09) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
          for GOD SAKE STOP
        • bvi (10/04/2016, 11:25) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
          Ignorance is a hell of a thing.....get to know your rights and keep fighting them tooth and nail until you get justice.
    • @ Bunny (10/04/2016, 11:34) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
      From where you stand in the BVI every other country seems to be better than the one in which you live. Every other country seems to be paradise.
    • Tallfat (10/04/2016, 13:26) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
      Where is the vision here? When the old banco building was converted to a Court for some exorbitant fee I was amazed. Everybody knew it would be just a matter of a few months before the cry for space would be sounding. Not a smart move then and it's costing mucho $$$$$$ to do the things it was not designed to do. That is only one part of the issue as it is the same for the High Court and magistrate court alike. Victim, defendant and witnesses have no proper place to sit at the magistrate court when the matter comes up. Security at those institution is poor and despite the recent gun find by the Police it has not change one bit. I will support a grand building that can accommodate all the courts insted of continuing to throw away good money in fixer-uppers.
  • Money Tree (08/04/2016, 19:03) Like (5) Dislike (0) Reply
    Too many offices ..eliminate some offices and you have more than enough space... Why do everyone need to have an office of their own. Why can't they share office. Free up the space for the purpose of the court..
  • Where is Myron? (08/04/2016, 21:19) Like (2) Dislike (2) Reply
    Myron is a lawyer...he could have take the US$1M he spend on building a wall at the high school and build a proper court building and office for the people. It still open to him to do it...I would vote him in next election if he did!
  • SCB (08/04/2016, 23:52) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    legal system in a mess but we will be watching how the little that we have is spent!!!
  • tola (09/04/2016, 09:25) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    The present magistrate court site could be constructed into a 4 story building with adequate space for Registry and judges court rooms on 2 floors.
  • Tallfat (10/04/2016, 13:12) Like (0) Dislike (1) Reply
    @ where is Myron. That's a good question but I believe you forget ask where is Vanterpool with the 30Mil and counting from the pier + other projects that just never get done properly and of course the Premier who besides not paying local artist for their work, has not collected 40Mil from business to failing to have proper management and accounting for the moneys. So yes don't just play favorites with your targeting cause others have spend, misspent and cannot account for moneys far more than 1Mil.


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.