Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

Woe to you, columnists and commentators

July 13th, 2013 | Tags: Dickson Igwe columnist commentator radio TV
Dickson Igwe. Photo: supplied
By Dickson Igwe

A series of article on the political pulse of the Virgin Islands as midterm approaches states that opinion givers have gotten a bad rap recently. This story investigates why this is.

It has not been a good time for the columnist and commentator. And in this group one can include talk show hosts, whether on radio or television. The commentator has fallen to new lows in the estimation of Joe Public. There are reasons why this is!   

One can allude to various causes for this phenomenon. For example, a prominent radio talk show host, and someone this contributor and columnist considers a friend, and who he greatly respects, made an untypical misstep, in making certain assertions a numbers of days ago, and on his show it would appear. As a result, he brought hot coals pouring down on the heads of writers and public forum speakers in the Virgin Islands. But why was this? 

Policy maker, media commentator, and activist: different roles 

Well, a story on an online media of July 8, 2013, titled, COLUMNISTS, TALK SHOW HOSTS, IGNORED BY GOVERNMENT, stated that a certain talk show host had complained that, ‘’ columnists and commentators are being ignored by government-. ‘’ Yes, this assertion of his albeit accurate, was clearly a misstep. Why? 

Because it clearly missed what the commentator and columnist is all about, in his or her writing, and public discussion call. It is imperative the public understands that a commentator is simply a person who discusses news and current affairs events, whether social, economic, political, and sporting, on written media, such as the newspaper and online blog, or on radio and television. 

A columnist on the other hand focuses on writing. He or she writes commentaries and opinion pieces in a newspaper or magazine, including the ubiquitous online media. Often, the stories written by the columnist are discussed by the radio and TV commentator, who may invite a columnist or contributor on to their show or programme. And vice versa: the columnist or contributor to a newspaper may write a story about a radio or television discussion that matters, in an Op Ed piece. 

There is a symbiotic relationship between these two frequently indistinct groups of opinion givers. But know this: the task of these often public figures ends in their giving their opinion on a matter or issue. And most commentators are quite happy to leave it at that! But for the Op Ed writer or talk show host, going beyond giving a personal, albeit informed opinion, on a matter, is frequently a slippery and dangerous slope; especially when the foray is into the realm of the policy maker and politician. This is the role of the activist, and when the commentator becomes a social or political activist then he or she is in a new and much different ballgame. 

Commentators may or may not influence the course of events in community and society. When they do influence critical matters, then that is simply because this is a feature of the national media beast. And it is done, or should be done, unintentionally. 

Commentators are not called to influence governments and policy makers. And they attempt to do so at their own peril in this writer’s opinion. Yes, they may do so indirectly, just as any other man or woman on the street could, by voicing their opinion on a matter, an opinion which falls on the ears of the powerful. And yes, of course, the commentator gets the benefit of the public pulpit when formulating and expressing his opinion. The activist on the other hand may be a commentator, but the activist’s role is to clearly influence public opinion, in the pursuit of a cause he or she may hold dear. 

The influence of the media on public opinion 

OK, this story is not about the activist. It is about the commentator. And the journalistic and media professions are called the ‘Fourth Estate’ for a good reason. The press, whether in the form of the reporter, investigative journalist, columnist, or commentator, knowingly or unknowingly, often influences public opinion: especially the opinion of the reading, watching, listening, and thinking public. But the Fourth Estate is certainly not, in any way, expected or required to influence or direct public policy, or the affairs of state. When the Fourth Estate influences politics, it often does so unwittingly and unknowingly; and this is so because it is given that privilege by the all powerful public. 

This influence on the public mind is a good thing. It keeps the powers that be, namely governments and powerful individuals and institutions in check. And it does so by making them more cautious, transparent and accountable. 

Media and politics: a frequently combustible relationship 

However, public policy and its direction is the arena of the politician, policy maker, and the voter, especially at election time. Or it is changed by the people in mass movement, uprising, or revolution, which can become necessary: the Egyptian model. This is where the activist is at his or her Nirvana, in their element. When commentators get too involved in power politics, they frequently take a hit. And that is what has happened recently in the Virgin Islands. 

Yes, the commentator may voice an opinion on political matters, but if he or she is not careful, he or she is frequently muddied by politics. That is why it is seldom that the voter puts the commentator on the hot seat of political power after an election. The world of politics is full of journalists and their ilk, with political ambition, that have gone crashing into the barriers during a political race. 

This is not because the commentator is not qualified to rule. It is because the voter, and reading and thinking public, expect the commentator or opinion giver to perform a clearly different task: the task of informing the public, and giving an informed opinion. The task of ruling in a modern democracy is left to the political leader. 

The public expects the commentator to stick to the task of writing and discussing news and social events. Whether the public accepts the opinion of the commentator or not, is the public’s own business, not the commentator’s. When the commentator comes out crying that his or her views are not being seriously considered by power, it smacks of narcissism. 

When commentators write on political topics, the wise ones understand that great care is required. One misstep or better stated overstep, and they better watch it.  For example, this political observer frequently writes a political story. And he has made his fair share of missteps in the past. However, he tries his best to leave subjectivity in the closet, and pull out his objective cloak. This is crucial. And make no mistake about it, like everyone else he has a ‘back to watch.’  

Another thing is this: journalists and commentators are to report, assess, and discuss, the great events of the day, nothing more and nothing less. When the commentator attempts to go further than this, and to overtly influence public opinion, he or she frequently hits a wall. The commentator’s motives are easily discerned by a much more intelligent public. Yes, the step from opinion writer or speaker, to opinion former and influencer, in other words, towards becoming an activist, is a road full of potholes, full of peril. It is not to be trod by the feint hearted!

To be continued

Connect with Dickson Igwe on Facebook and Twitter

5 Responses to “Woe to you, columnists and commentators ”



Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.