Got TIPS or BREAKING NEWS? Please call 1-284-442-8000 direct/can also WhatsApp same number or Email ALL news to:newsvino@outlook.com;                               ads call 1-284-440-6666

The UK could take over MF if urgent changes are not made- John S. Duncan

- United Kingdom appointed Governor wrote the Premier in February 2016 warning of urgent corrections to be made & information to be provided or else
From left: Premier of the Virgin Islands Dr The Hon D. Orlando Smith, Governor John S. Duncan OBE and Financial Secretary Neil M. Smith. Photo: VINO/File
From left: Central Administration Complex and Government House. Correspondence from Governor John S. Duncan OBE shows that he is not pleased with the financial management of the territory's funds. Photo: VINO/File
From left: Central Administration Complex and Government House. Correspondence from Governor John S. Duncan OBE shows that he is not pleased with the financial management of the territory's funds. Photo: VINO/File
ROAD TOWN, Tortola, VI- While our newsroom is not the “WikiLeaks” of the Virgin Islands (VI), we continue to obtain (most times dropped off anonymously at our office) many government documents on a wide variety of government information.

We continue as professional journalists to use our discretion not to compromise National Security or any extremely restrictive and confidential information that can give VI competitors an advantage.

John S. Duncan two-faced; Another Hillary R. Clinton?

However, it appears from many of the information that Governor John S. Duncan OBE appears to be two-faced and a hypocrite.

He has been likened to the Democratic Presidential Candidate Hillary R. Clinton, where there is a public position and one in private.

While in public and in media interviews for the past two years he has been praising the National Democratic Party (NDP) government, letting the public know they are angels and continue to do everything right and most often confusing the public when insisting that there is no corruption or mismanagement of funds. However, behind closed doors, in Cabinet and in many correspondences to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office and Premier Dr The Honourable D. Orlando Smith, he is taking the opposite positions.

Need audited accounts or else!

Take for example, one of many letters written to the Premier, dated February 11, 2016 and copied to the Deputy Governor and the Financial Secretary.

In that letter Mr Duncan, who is shaping up to be one of the most unpopular governors to ever serve the British Overseas Territory, warned the Government of Dr Smith about the blatant violation of the VI Constitution over formal audits of the Government Accounts.

“I note that my predecessor Governor McClearly wrote to you in June 2014 expressing concerns that the BVIG was in breach of their obligations under the Constitution having not presented audited accounts to the Assembly for several years.”

The governor in his letter also mentioned that an audit was done by Price Waterhouse Coopers and it had “revealed serious flaws in the Government’s accounts.”

Governor Duncan warned the NDP administration after almost two years that this situation needs to be “rectified as soon as possible.”

In suggesting that if this matter is not addressed, the Senior Foreign and Commonwealth Service civil servant Duncan warned that without a formal audit of the Government Accounts the FCO “cannot be certain as to the extent of their own contingent liability.”

Opposition has warned public already

The Opposition has been calling for the audited accounts for years going back to 2012, however, the governor has been silent in Public on the matter, something the Virgin Islands Party (VIP) Opposition regard as lack of good governance. In response, Governor Duncan said he is not “an internal police.”

The VIP has also brought out evidence of mismanagement of funds. In public, the Governor is saying he is satisfied with how the NDP regime is managing the public purse but in letters and communique to the FCO he is saying another.

He also offered someone from the UK to help manage the Ministry of Finance; however, this notion was rejected by Financial Secretary Neil M. Smith.

Example of mismanagement –Duncan

In the same letter, Governor Duncan is agreeing that there is Government mismanagement of funds. He made reference in the February 11, 2016 letter to Premier Smith about a request to provide $96,000 for catering at a training course for public servants which he described as “particularly egregious.”

However, the letter did not provide for which Ministry or Department made the request or who offered the catering services.

Governor Duncan has asked Dr Smith and the Cabinet to “lead a concerted and structured effort to reduce wasteful expenditure.”

Part 1 of a series of articles on correspondence between the Governor and the Premier 

40 Responses to “The UK could take over MF if urgent changes are not made- John S. Duncan”

  • Nonotone (24/10/2016, 17:06) Like (13) Dislike (20) Reply

    Don't trust them w...... boys. Behind closed doors, they want to shut us down long time all because of jealousy, but it is time we start to think and fend for ourselves. We need to find way to go forward without Colonial association. It is time, man. They must rule or else. Learn your history. They started it; we must end the relationship, not have them back in our saddle. Send them back to UK to deal with Brexit and Fixit.

    • John (25/10/2016, 09:15) Like (11) Dislike (0) Reply
      You are saying you do not want the constitution complied with nor do you want any accountability in government. Where will be the check and balance, who will force the government to comply with the rules under your regime? Don't these things matter, Nonotone? Or, do you just care about your party interest? It can turn out that you, yourself, may one day be a victim of your wishes.
  • Slaverydone (24/10/2016, 17:10) Like (16) Dislike (33) Reply

    The day they take over Ministry of Finance is the day we back in Slavery. Where is the referendum in the Constitution for us to chart our own destiny? We are not going back in Colonial days with these w...... boys.

    • dog man (25/10/2016, 09:07) Like (19) Dislike (0) Reply
      it's not the w----- Man putting u back there! Who too Blame who too blame ?
    • John (25/10/2016, 11:56) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
      The above also applies to you too, Slaverydone, how can corruption be investigated? These matters need to be understood before this talk about independence. Don't you care about the rights of others?
  • Xxx (24/10/2016, 17:12) Like (31) Dislike (1) Reply
    Well sah thing to talk
  • ccc (24/10/2016, 18:22) Like (15) Dislike (0) Reply
    This is hot
  • Hmm (24/10/2016, 18:48) Like (9) Dislike (0) Reply
    WOW!
  • Law Abiding citizen (24/10/2016, 18:52) Like (44) Dislike (4) Reply
    The governor is right, and I hope it happens. Enough squandering of our funds.
  • .... (24/10/2016, 18:53) Like (11) Dislike (0) Reply
    The governor is the Undercover Boss.
  • What?!!!! (24/10/2016, 19:01) Like (15) Dislike (0) Reply
    And this is only Part 1? o_O
  • dog (24/10/2016, 19:29) Like (22) Dislike (0) Reply
    Let me get some popcorn vino
  • belonger (24/10/2016, 19:57) Like (19) Dislike (1) Reply
    Lol u were warned by the Hon. Julian Fraser that this could happen during the 2015 election campaign, but u listened to the NDP who said he was telling lies. Now see who tbe liars are now. Now a possible white FS from where u don't have to guess. A white Premiere next.
  • wize up (24/10/2016, 19:59) Like (46) Dislike (0) Reply
    Some of us think the governor not doing anything but I got news for some of us!!!!
  • Wendy (24/10/2016, 20:43) Like (27) Dislike (14) Reply
    Makes sense for Gov Duncan to not publicly announce his concerns about the bureaucratic concerns he might have with the Government. To do so, he would solve little and cause much unnecessary panic and outcry from citizens who are determined to see a failed Government.. It appears to me that he has much confidence in the current Gov and is confident that things will fall into place in due time. What might appear to be unorthodox could simply be a means to accomplish certain goals , a means to an end for positive achievements. Rigidly following prescribed patterns is not always best. At times a deviation ,best used by skilled and independent thinkers is the best solution for a successful outcome.

    Okay,now I,m ready for licks!!!



    • @ Wendy (24/10/2016, 22:06) Like (19) Dislike (2) Reply
      you need to read some history from blogging piss
    • chad (25/10/2016, 06:29) Like (1) Dislike (3) Reply
      You are a real ass kisser will like to put my foot up you ass along with couple Anglo Saxton
  • Political Observer (24/10/2016, 20:49) Like (18) Dislike (4) Reply
    This is serious ting folks! The Ministry of Finance is a vital, plumb Ministry. If it were to be snatched from locals due alleged mismanagement and constitutional violations, it is an indication that locals cannot effectively managed its own affairs, especially financial affairs. The Governor's office apprised Government of the financial management issue back in 2014 but the info was hidden from us. If the info was not leaked, we would not have known about it. Was this the driver for the snap election in 2015 before the opposition got wind of it ? Is this the driver for the increasing call for independence? Well, now that the cat is out of the bag, what is government plan of action? Will the Premier give a national address?

    It is not a surprise that the Governor is making a mockery of us saying that all is well but allegedly telling the FCO a different story. Of course, the FCO and the Governor's office will be reading from the same script. Who to blame for this allegedly budding financial fiasco? Is it the Minister of Finance for letting ministers do as they like without any effective oversight? Was the Governor's refusal to commissioned a Commission of Inquiry into the Tortola Pier Park project a plan to give the government more rope to strangle itself and make the case for the U.K. to take over?
    • NPolitico (25/10/2016, 09:09) Like (9) Dislike (1) Reply
      @Political Observer, real talk. Great political instincts and insight. But you ever saw green mules flying? Well, you will quicker see green mules flying than for the government to shed light on what is going on financially. Fellow Virgin Islanders, countrymen, it is time for us to demand transparency, accountability and responsibility. We cannot stay silent and boil like frogs. It is alleged that if you put a frog in a pan of cold water and gradually heat it the frog will boil to death. However, on the other hand, if you throw a frog in a pan of boiling water it will jump out. Well nationally the heat is on and it is time to peacefully act. Remember that people with power do not freely give it up; it has to be wrested from them. We need to agitate peacefully for our future well-being today, for tommorow may be much too, too, too late. Remember TCI?
  • Helmet (24/10/2016, 20:51) Like (9) Dislike (5) Reply
    So Mr Governor is caught in another LIE
  • Keep it real. (24/10/2016, 21:32) Like (17) Dislike (0) Reply
    All these people we put our trust in doing. "Enriching themselves" people are suffering and ignored. A take over may not be a bad thing..
  • wize up (24/10/2016, 21:52) Like (3) Dislike (1) Reply
    It is no coincidence the governor sanctioned the DPP must be from the UK also the Commissioner of Police: from the UK( listen up; brother tell us they stab you in the back and claim you weren't looking)
  • Real (24/10/2016, 22:13) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    This is along time coming and we shouldn't just take this as talk from this Governor. This is what the UK has been planning believe it or not, soon after this I bet they going for customs.
  • hah (24/10/2016, 22:43) Like (9) Dislike (1) Reply
    Well Well Wow, Next election them redshirts better stay the eff away from my yard.
  • Yes (24/10/2016, 23:35) Like (17) Dislike (0) Reply
    The axe soon fall. All of these frantic calls for independence by these NDP polititrickians are simply to avoid accountability. Bring it Gov Bring it! These NDP Politrickians have had enough rope to sling round their own necks.
  • Sam (25/10/2016, 06:32) Like (13) Dislike (0) Reply
    The point here is simple ,it is the responsibility of the financial secretary to make sure that those audits are completed
    But if you were paying attention you will se where the real problem is,who has been the FS for the last ten years, and the last audited government financials were
    In 2007.
    • bingo! (25/10/2016, 09:45) Like (4) Dislike (0) Reply
      We like to play deaf, blind and dumb around here! Look at the senior persons in Government over the past 10 years and look at the issues we have been experiencing regardless of which party held the Government/Cabinet. It's clear as day to see who/what our major issues are but we conveniently blame the easiest ones to blame instead of dealing with the issues head on. Keep on keeping on until there's nothing to keep on.
  • Donald trump (25/10/2016, 08:25) Like (5) Dislike (0) Reply
    The NDP Government is Crooked like a 3 $ Bill..
  • Wiki Leaks (25/10/2016, 08:55) Like (2) Dislike (0) Reply
    We either Raise taxes or lay off,the treasury is Dry..
  • dpp (25/10/2016, 09:30) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    Lord I had run from the BVI
  • Ourpeople (25/10/2016, 09:44) Like (7) Dislike (17) Reply
    It is sad when we see people on here blogging saying "Bring it on, Governor." Do you think the UK really care about the Virgin Islands? Because of where we have come in Financial Services to compete against them and Europe, all of a sudden we appear important. People, history would teach us that the same British enslaved our ancestors. and meted out harsh administration on them. When it was not profitable for their West Indian companies, they abandoned their businesses and forgot all about us. Who was fending for us these past 30 years? We need to wake up and rule ourselves. Any local politician is better than any Colonial master. Study your history. Had they not hid the history books from us, we would never be in this era thinking that they are our Saviour. This is a sad, red-letter day in our modern history. Why do we sit idly by and watch our demise and not chart our own destiny? DPP, Prison, Police, Governor, Finance, Commercial Court, Arbitration Court; isn't that leadership at the helm by all Europeans? We prefer to be poor than to be ruled by Colonial Masters. Trust me, they haven't changed their mentality from that era.
  • Scary Mary (25/10/2016, 14:00) Like (16) Dislike (0) Reply
    It is my opinion that the government is deliberately ignoring the warnings and requests for financial accountability and financial responsibility from the Governor and the FCO, in order to glean support for their oh so desperate wish to gain independence.

    Those in government are well aware that the majority of the people are dead set against Independence, but they also know that if those darned "Colonials" appear to be trying to push us around, they will can get a majority of people to back their reckless and way too premature wish for independence.

    For heaven's sake, DON'T fall for this ploy! You are being manipulated!

    The Governor has been trying to keep things under wraps, believing the government would comply and everything would get smoothed over. Little did he realize that he is being "handled".

    I don't believe they have ANY intention of complying with the Governor or the FCO. They are doing everything they can to force the issue so they can speed up the process of independence. I am certain they wish to cozy up to their Chinese buddies in more ways than one.

    If you don't believe me, just wait. Things are being put in place while we sit back and watch it all happen right in front of our faces.
  • Soooooo (25/10/2016, 15:48) Like (0) Dislike (9) Reply
    All this hullabaloo about something you all know nothing about based on leaked documents supposedly and why aren't these letters /copies being shown along with this great big story?
    NDP will be in power a long long time with such nonsensical folks catching every bonee thrown at them by detractors.
  • PwC?!?! (25/10/2016, 22:49) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    They don't even have an audit function on island. Many other firms who have invested in BVI for decades have plenty of skill and capacity for this. It is a disgrace that they were selected.
  • fyah ras (26/10/2016, 00:39) Like (10) Dislike (1) Reply
    Judgement yard. Fire pon them white boys and the NDP crooks!
  • Oy!! (26/10/2016, 06:23) Like (1) Dislike (0) Reply
    Oy Govnah, the UKs only concern in the BVI is as it relates to its National Security..so can we pls get some funding to place CCTVs at least in the central and business areas??? ASAP? Can we get some proper training in investigations on the police force instead of loading off retirees? Can we do something to continuously improve border control at the ports, whether sea or air? Oright mayte??
  • W*F (28/10/2016, 18:42) Like (0) Dislike (0) Reply
    Better late than never. I hope it happens immediately.


Create a comment


Create a comment

Disclaimer: Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) welcomes your thoughts, feedback, views, bloggs and opinions. However, by posting a blogg you are agreeing to post comments or bloggs that are relevant to the topic, and that are not defamatory, liable, obscene, racist, abusive, sexist, anti-Semitic, threatening, hateful or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be excluded permanently from making contributions. Please view our declaimer above this article. We thank you in advance for complying with VINO's policy.

Follow Us On

Disclaimer: All comments posted on Virgin Islands News Online (VINO) are the sole views and opinions of the commentators and or bloggers and do not in anyway represent the views and opinions of the Board of Directors, Management and Staff of Virgin Islands News Online and its parent company.